Comments to the Census Bureau Opposing Changes to the Decennial Census

Posted

Thank you for the opportunity to submit comments on the Department of Commerce notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM), “Changing Residence Criteria for the Decennial Census and Restricting Demographic Questions,” published in the Federal Register on September 10, 2026 (FR doc. 2027-18481). On behalf of Children’s HealthWatch, we write in strong opposition to the NPRM and urge the US Census Bureau to immediately withdraw its proposal and leave in place the current census that accurately and fairly counts all community members. 

Children’s HealthWatch is a nonpartisan network of pediatricians, public health researchers, and policy experts who examine how policy decisions affect the health and well-being of young children and their families. We accomplish this by interviewing caregivers of young children under age four in emergency departments and primary care clinics in four U.S. cities: Boston, MA; Minneapolis, MN; Little Rock, AR; and Philadelphia, PA. Since 1998, we have interviewed more than 80,000 caregivers. We then analyze those data to determine the impact of policy decisions on the health and development of young children, and share our findings with policy experts, advocates, researchers, and legislators at the state and national level. We see firsthand the positive impacts robust public policies have on families with young children, and similarly the negative impacts when public policy choices are insufficient. 

The census is the nation’s foremost source of data to understand how our communities are doing, who lives in them, and how they are growing and changing. Census data is used to determine the number of seats each state has in the House of Representatives, directly shaping residents’ representation in government. Additionally, this data provides essential information to help governments, businesses, and nonprofits decide where to invest resources and how to better serve communities. Demographic data collected through the Census is essential for identifying and addressing discrimination and disparities, enforcing civil rights laws, and ensuring equal opportunity for all people living in the US. It is vital that the decennial census meets the requirements set in the Constitution, and provides a fair, accurate, and transparent count to understand the most accurate composition of our communities.

The proposed changes to the decennial census will undermine democracy, public health, and the health and well-being of families and whole communities across the nation. The NPRM would change both who is counted in the census and what data are gathered, including barring certain non-citizen residents from participation and ending the practice of collecting race and ethnicity data. These changes would make it virtually impossible to have accurate information that informs decisions about our government and the disbursement of resources. The census is the primary source of this kind of data and dismantling it will obscure disparities present across the country. Ultimately, the NPRM will create a break in information that will undo many other efforts to fairly represent and care for all communities across the country.

The NPRM will lead to an undercount of children, jeopardizing accurate representation and equitable allocation of resources

Under the proposed rule, only lawfully permanent residents (LPRs) would be counted in the decennial census – excluding thousands of other immigrants who have documentation necessary to live, work, study, and raise their families here in the United States, like H1-B visa holders, refugees, asylees, and international students. Additionally, the NPRM excludes undocumented residents from the census, obscuring the true population and distribution of people in the nation. Beyond the direct consequences of that exclusion, the proposed changes are also likely to deter immigrants who remain eligible from participating in the census. This is especially consequential as immigrants are already traditionally undercounted in the census. Further, the proposed rule would impact the count of all children, including US citizens in mixed-status families. More than one in four children living in the US has at least one immigrant parent. 

Overt exclusion of one group creates fear for others, and has far-reaching health implications for whole communities. Policies of fear and punishment that target the immigrant community, like those laid out in the NPRM, are associated with toxic stress that compromise the health of current and future generations. Experiences of toxic stress in childhood are associated with adverse health effects throughout adulthood, such as immune dysregulation, increased depressive symptoms, and chronic diseases. 

The NPRM is particularly concerning for young children, a population with a long-standing undercount in decennial censuses among immigrant families and non-immigrant families alike. Because census data inform how the federal government disperses funding to communities, lower response rates will dramatically lower the allocation of funds to state and local governments for social service, health, and education programs that are essential for the health and well-being of all children and their families. Despite the changes in the NPRM that exclude immigrant populations, state and local governments will still have to care for and provide services to these community members. The change in census will deprive them of the resources needed to do that, which could lead to program cuts that impact everyone, regardless of citizenship status.

Moreover, because the census happens only once every 10 years, the undercount would be held in place for a decade. For a young child, this could mean that their schools and other key programs and infrastructure would be underfunded throughout their formative years of elementary schooling and into middle school. The Census Bureau estimates that data from the last decennial census in 2020 were used in whole or in part in the distribution of more than $2.8 trillion in federal assistance in fiscal year 2021; the NPRM will make the allocation of this money less data-driven and more inefficient. A lack of adequate funding to support critical programs will have a devastating impact on the health of all residents, particularly children and those living with low incomes. Funding that does not correspond to actual populations will make it even harder for states to administer critical support programs that serve and protect the health and well-being of children and families with low incomes, including Medicaid, preschool and K-12 education programs, and housing support. 

Material hardships in childhood, including poor education quality and lack of access to healthcare, are shown to have negative impacts that last a lifetime, including lower educational attainment, increased rates of chronic disease, and lower wages into adulthood., At the same time, when families are hardship-free, both children and parents are more likely to have good health.

Eliminating race and ethnicity data collection will undermine efforts to identify and address disparities

The NPRM also removes key race and ethnicity questions that help governments and nonprofits assess disparities in their communities and the efficiency of programs addressing those disparities. The NPRM will undermine these efforts and obscure disparities, making it harder for researchers and governments to analyze the impact of public policies design and implementation, ultimately leading to inefficiency and undue harm on a wide variety of communities.

Furthermore, demographic Census data is necessary to enforce civil rights laws, such as the Voting Rights Act and the Fair Housing Act, and to ensure equal opportunity for all US residents. Without this information, it will be harder for communities to identify and address longstanding racial, ethnic, and other disparities or to serve underserved communities. In turn, the proposal will harm nonprofits that work to advance equitable access to services and healthy communities by making it nearly impossible to make critical decisions about where to invest resources, undermining their ability to pursue their mission.

Conclusion

The census helps communities understand how many people live in an area and where populations are growing and changing. Census data inform decisions about resources for schools, roads, hospitals, public health, transportation and other essential community infrastructure. Census data shape our representation in Congress. The changes proposed in the NPRM will jeopardize all of these systems at the expense of families across the nation. It will also deter immigrant families from participating, which will further exacerbate racial and ethnic disparities. These changes are harmful and unconstitutional, and we urge the Census Bureau to rescind them immediately.

The post Comments to the Census Bureau Opposing Changes to the Decennial Census appeared first on Children's HealthWatch.

Testimonies, Statements, and Letters, Equity, Health and Development, Immigration, Legislation, Public Assistance Programs, Social Determinants of Health